Improved Decision Making

Probabilistic Thinking

The First Key Is Just To Be Less Sure About Everything, And Then Apply Probabilistic Thinking.



Improved Decision Making - Introduction

To set the scene for improved decision making let's consider this TED presentation by Julia Galef in which she argues that having good judgment, making accurate predictions, making good decisions, is mostly about which mindset you're in.

Why you think you're right - even if you're wrong - aka "Motivated Reasoning"...!

Soldier Mindset - Defend At All Costs

"So I'd like you to imagine for a moment that you're a soldier in the heat of battle. Maybe you're a Roman foot soldier or a medieval archer or maybe you're a Zulu warrior. Regardless of your time and place, there are some things that are constant. Your adrenaline is elevated, and your actions are stemming from these deeply ingrained reflexes, reflexes rooted in a need to protect yourself and your side and to defeat the enemy."

Scout Mindset - Seek To Understand What's Really There

"So now, I'd like you to imagine playing a very different role, that of the scout. The scout's job is not to attack or defend. The scout's job is to understand. The scout is the one going out, mapping the terrain, identifying potential obstacles. And the scout may hope to learn that, say, there's a bridge in a convenient location across a river. But above all, the scout wants to know what's really there, as accurately as possible. And in a real, actual army, both the soldier and the scout are essential.

But you can also think of each of these roles as a mindset - a metaphor for how all of us process information and ideas in our daily lives".



Watch With Full Transcript

Julia closes her presentation with a question:

"...if we really want to improve our judgment as individuals and as societies, what we need most is not more instruction in logic or rhetoric or probability or economics, even though those things are quite valuable.

But what we most need to use those principles well is scout mindset.

  • We need to change the way we feel.
  • We need to learn how to feel proud instead of ashamed when we notice we might have been wrong about something.
  • We need to learn how to feel intrigued instead of defensive when we encounter some information that contradicts our beliefs.

So the question I want to leave you with is:

What do you most yearn for?

Do you yearn to defend your own beliefs?

Or do you yearn to see the world as clearly as you possibly can?"






3 Keys To Improved Decision Making

Here are 3 keys that will improve your ability to predict and assess the effects of your choices and thus lead to improved decision making.


[1] Be less sure

Overconfidence is the bias that is most prevalent, especially among men, the rich, and experts.

Not everyone is overconfident but nevertheless it's a good working rule to assume that you’re more confident about each step of the decision-making process than you ought to be.

So the first key to improved decision making is just to be less sure about everything.

If you can accept that you're most likely to be over-confident about the logic of your decision making process then consider alternative outcomes than the ones you expect or are hoping for.


[2] “How often does that typically happen?”

The best start point for improved decision making is to ask the question: “How often does that typically happen?”

For example, if you are considering working with a business startup, you could ask: "What percentage of startups fail/succeed?"

This will help you form a prediction. It is referred to as the base rate or as I would refer to it, the base line.

You can ask the same question when you are making a judgement call on potential outcomes, for example: "What percentage of times has outcome A occurred compared with outcome B?"

The aim with both the prediction and the judgment aspects of improved decision making is move beyond the specifics of the  scenario under review and to look at the broader picture with other similar scenarios.



[3] Use probabilistic thinking 


"Probabilistic thinking is essentially trying to estimate, using some tools of math and logic, the likelihood of any specific outcome coming to pass."





Probabilistic Thinking



Shane Parrish of Farnham Street summarised this wonderfully:



    "Successfully thinking in shades of probability means roughly identifying what matters, coming up with a sense of the odds, doing a check on our assumptions, and then making a decision.

    More people talk about probability than use it to think and make decisions.

    Probability is full of nuance not the convenience of black and white thinking.

    We can act with a higher level of certainty in complex, unpredictable situations.

    We can never know the future with exact precision.

    Probabilistic thinking is an extremely useful tool to evaluate how the world will most likely look so that we can effectively strategize."



In a recent tweet storm Shane expanded on this very succinctly:

"Probability means different things to different people.

  • Probabilistic thinking is essentially trying to estimate, using some tools of math and logic, the likelihood of any specific outcome coming to pass.
  • The core of probabilistic thinking is understanding that nearly infinite alternative outcomes could have taken place than did.
  • This means nearly infinite possibilities are possible going forward, which doesn’t mean they are equally probable.
  • Probability is about more than the odds. It’s about how we weigh our knowledge, the methods in which we use to deal with our ignorance, and understanding that in the real world the range of outcomes is rarely finite."



5 lessons you can put to use:

  1. Tiny errors compound. Over a long enough time period, even small imperfections overpower perfect assumptions. Change is constant. Just as success plants the seeds of failure, failure plants the seeds of success.
  2. Our knowledge is more uncertain than we’d like. We assign a much higher probability to our own opinions than warranted. Everything we see is filtered through the lens of wanting to be right.
  3. In the real world, probability never seems as simple as it does in the textbook. There is no six-sided die asking us to place a bet on the odds of rolling a 2. Small errors in our measurement of risk can cause massive errors in outcome magnitude.
  4. There is a difference between how likely something is to happen and its impact. Small odds can hide asymmetric impacts.
  5. The worst thing that has ever happened is not the worst thing that could happen.







Applying Probabilistic Thinking

The ABC of probabilistic thinking:

Avoid

Binary

Choice

This is about living with complexity and improved decision making based on probabilities.

# Identify The Relevant Variables

# Attach Probabilities To Each

# Apply Bayesian Thinking - by reviewing each new variable in the context of all prior information you hold and see if it:

  • Changes your previous assessment of probability, or
  • Changes your current assessment of the new variable.


# Understand The Variations - are you are dealing with variations within a predictable variation from the mean [Bell curve] or are there extreme variations [Fat tail] which have a higher probability of occurring.

  • For example, the range of variation in the height of people is not that great. The variation from the smallest dwarf to the largest giant is limited within a predictable range.This fits with the Bell curve.
  • Whereas the range of variation on people's incomes can be huge for example $10k per annum to $10million + per annum and thus the chance of someone in a sample group with an income massively above the mean is far more probable

# Understand Your Optimism Bias - our probability estimates are more likely wrong on the over optimistic side and also more likely underestimated on the side of something going wrong.




The Good Judgment Project


    The Good Judgment Project [GJP] was formed in 2011 with the objective of finding out whether some people are naturally better than others at prediction and whether prediction performance could be enhanced.

    The Good Judgment Project was one of five academic research teams that competed in an innovative tournament funded by the Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity (IARPA), in which forecasters were challenged to answer the types of geopolitical and economic questions that U.S. intelligence agencies pose to their analysts.

    The IARPA initiative ran from 2011 to 2015 and recruited more than 25,000 forecasters who made well over a million predictions on topics ranging from whether Greece would exit the eurozone to the likelihood of a leadership turnover in Russia to the risk of a financial panic in China.

    The Good Judgment Project decisively won the tournament—besting even the intelligence community’s own analysts.

    The Good Judgment Project identified the traits shared by the best-performing forecasters in the Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity tournament, and these are all qualities required for improved decision making:





    # Philosophical Approach  

    • Cautious
    • They understand that few things are certain

    # Humble

    • They appreciate their limits

    # Nondeterministic

    • They don’t assume that what happens is meant to be

    # Abilities and Thinking Style

    • Open-minded
    • They see beliefs as hypotheses to be tested

    # Inquiring

    • They are intellectually curious and enjoy mental challenges

    # Reflective

    • They are introspective and self-critical

    # Numerate

    • They are comfortable with numbers

    # Analytical

    • They consider other views

    # Methods of Forecasting

    • Pragmatic
    • They are not wedded to any one idea or agenda

    # Synthesizing

    • They blend diverse views into their own

    # Probability-focused

    • They judge the probability of events not as certain or uncertain but as more or less likely

    # Thoughtful updaters

    • They change their minds when new facts warrant it

    # Intuitive shrinks

    • They are aware of their cognitive and emotional biases

    # Work Ethic

    • Improvement-minded
    • They strive to get better

    # Tenacious

    • They stick with a problem for as long as needed







Further Reading: Superforecasting

Return from "Improved Decision Making" to: Mental Models






Chinese (Traditional)EnglishFrenchGermanItalianRussianSpanishVietnamese


Custom Site Search


The Balanced Toolkit



The Balanced Life



3 Keys Solutions


Get new posts by email:

LATEST ARTICLES

  1. How To Stay Connected To Your True Source Of Power

    "Your ego's desire to be in control, your ego usurping the role of your higher self, disconnects you from your true source of power." A stone of help is a constant reminder to stay connected to your…

    Read More

  2. Dying To Self - To Gain All Give All

    "If You Want To Be Given Everything - Give Everything Up". “Tao Te Ching” Your ego is essential and does a wonderful job of running things for you and marshalling your mental and emotional resources t…

    Read More

  3. My Experience Of Mindfulness In Situations Of Imposed Change

    I found that the biggest key to all this is to behave and respond in ways that may seem completely alien to you by cultivating a very deep acceptance of what is. Many years ago my fortunes had change…

    Read More

  4. The Balanced Life

    The Key To Keeping Your Balance Is Knowing When You Lost It. The balanced life is one where you recognise the full spectrum of possible responses and have develop sufficient experience, insight and se…

    Read More

  5. Self Motivation - How To Motivate Yourself In Tough Times

    Our focus here is going to be on the heavy duty / big picture level motivation that you need to get you through tough times often involving imposed change that have large and perhaps dramatic impacts…

    Read More

  6. Your Higher Self - Your Hardwired Portal To The Universe

    Think of your conscious mind as a ship floating on the ocean of your subconscious mind, and above is the sky of your higher consciousness. When things are tough and you are starting to think that no…

    Read More

  7. How Can I Change My Mind?

    Whilst it is true that we can be taught, generally we won't change. Your mind is either working for you or, more typically, working against you. There is a part of your mind that is very happy with h…

    Read More

  8. Managing Personal Change Is Hard - Here's How You CAN Make It Work

    Whilst it is true that we can be taught, generally we won't change. You can waste years of your life (as I have done) and spend a fortune in various forms of introspection, analysis and therapy diggi…

    Read More

  9. Change Comes From Within

    "Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate." For much of my life I didn't understand that change comes from within, I used to believe that change wa…

    Read More

  10. How Things Are - The Inbuilt Design Flaw

    This is the nature of things. This is how things are. Nobody has the perfect life. We all struggle and strive to attain health, wealth and personal happiness. Yet these three big areas: our health, o…

    Read More




Support This Site